Following the war, Levick married Rachel Bedinger in Shepherdstown, Virginia, in 1791, and they had six children.

They are Sarah “Sallie” Levick; Mary Levick (born September 13, 1793); Elisabeth Levick (born in 1797), John Levick (born in 1798); Ann Levick; and Margaret Levick (born February 12, 1809). Levick died on December 18, 1817, at Shepherdstown, Jefferson County, West, and is buried in the “Old Episcopal Graveyard” in Shepherdstown. A DAR marker is present.

After the death of Caleb Levick, his widow and several of his children moved to the 400 acres of government-issued land in Jefferson County, Virginia.